Someone looking for a rose fragrance should not have to choose between “Perfume,” “New Arrivals,” “Reviews” and “Editor’s Picks” before finding a useful description of the scent. Each label makes sense on its own; together, they make readers guess where the site has filed the same subject. A fifth menu item called “Floral Fragrances” would merely give them another place to guess.
For a beauty publication, the fix is often to make existing routes clearer. A reader might arrive at a review of a London department-store launch, then want to compare notes, find application advice or check whether the collection is still current. Those next steps should be apparent on the article page, not buried in the main menu. Fragrance, skincare, makeup and fashion overlap in real life, even if a site needs tidy categories.
Find out where readers lose the thread
Start with a few ordinary tasks, not a proposed redesign. Ask someone to find a woody-fragrance review, guidance on using a newly launched skincare range or coverage of a designer’s beauty collaboration. Watch which labels they choose, where they backtrack and whether they give up and use search. Ask what they expected each label to contain. That tells you more than whether they think the design looks clean.
Site-search queries, if you have them, offer another clue. Repeated searches for “perfume notes” may mean the fragrance archive is hard to scan, not that it needs its own top-level menu item. Searches for a prominently featured brand may point to vague page titles or poorly labelled cards. Search data will not explain every hesitation, so compare it with observed tasks and the pages where readers enter the site. Plenty never see the home page first.
Keep the audit practical:
- Pick representative tasks: include a broad browse, a specific product search and a follow-on task from an article.
- Record the first choice: note which label a reader selects and what they expected behind it.
- Check landing pages: see where an article, campaign feature or search result lets the reader go next.
- Separate label problems from missing content: a clearer route cannot lead to a comparison that has never been written.
That last distinction matters. Renaming a category is a cosmetic fix if the real problem is an archive that mixes ingredient explainers, launch reports and finished-product reviews without telling readers which is which.

Give each existing category a job
Top-level categories should describe lasting parts of the publication, not this month’s campaigns. “Fragrance,” “Skincare,” “Makeup” and “Fashion & Beauty” can hold plenty of stories without acquiring a new menu item every time a house releases a collection. The labels should make sense to someone who has not followed the editorial calendar.
Look for categories that compete. If “Beauty News” and “New Launches” contain nearly identical posts, readers have little reason to choose one over the other. Define the difference, merge them if that makes more sense, or treat one as a format within a broader section. Equally, do not file a runway-inspired makeup story under “Fashion” solely because it mentions a designer. File it according to the reader’s main reason for opening it, then show the crossover in the article.
Keep primary labels literal. “The Dressing Table” sounds charming, but a new visitor cannot tell whether it holds reviews, interviews or shopping notes. Save the personality for the writing and visuals. “Discover” is even less helpful: it can become the digital drawer full of spare buttons, old receipts and one mysterious key.
Write useful introductions to category pages
An archive need not be a wall of thumbnails in date order. A short introduction can explain what belongs there and point to a few labelled routes. A fragrance page, for example, could distinguish reviews, guides to notes and new-release coverage. Show those as headings or featured selections within the page rather than piling them into the global menu. On a phone, keep the introduction short enough that readers can still see the articles.
Cards need titles that identify both subject and format. “A Study in Blue” might suit a campaign essay, but the card should also make clear which makeup collection it covers. That distinction is useful when several launches share a similar look.
Use the article page as a navigation surface
An article is often the first page a reader sees. If all the useful routes sit in the header, the site ignores the best clue it has: the story the reader chose. A citrus-fragrance review could point to an explanation of citrus notes or a comparison that puts its dry-down in context. It does not need a carousel of every perfume post from the season.
Links should answer the next likely question. After a skincare launch report, readers may want to know what is in the range, how the products differ and whether the brand provides clear instructions for use. If the blog has tested a product separately, call that destination a review; do not suggest the launch report contains hands-on findings. Clear routes can also help readers tell a brand claim from an editorial assessment. Anyone dealing with persistent skin concerns or reactions should seek individual advice from a qualified professional, rather than rely on an article.
Put links where their purpose is clear: next to a relevant passage, in a small “related coverage” block with specific titles, or at the end of a section that leads naturally to another story. Do not link the same destination repeatedly or make every brand mention clickable. Readers need direction, not a thicket of exits. For editors, guidance on writing useful headings for beauty reviews can also make a long review easier to scan before someone decides to leave it.

Make overlapping subjects findable without duplicating menus
Beauty stories rarely stay in one neat box. A fragrance might be covered through its iris note, bottle design, advertising campaign and the fashion house behind it. Each angle does not need a main menu slot. Use categories for the principal subject and tags or selected topic pages for recurring secondary themes.
Be selective with those secondary routes. A “rose” topic page earns its place if it gathers enough varied, relevant material for someone exploring the note; a single brief launch mention does not justify one. A designer page also needs a clear remit—beauty collaborations and campaigns, perhaps, rather than every passing reference in a makeup review. Thin, inconsistent pages create more places to get lost.
Two articles about the same product can serve different purposes. A launch report may record the shades and campaign imagery; a later review may assess wear and application. Keep both if each contributes something, and label the connection so readers do not mistake an announcement for an evaluation. If older posts simply repeat the same facts, consolidating them may help more than building a topic page around the repetition.
Improve search before asking the menu to do its work
Readers after an exact brand, shade or fragrance name will often search, however well organised the site is. Give them a visible search field or a clearly labelled control without crowding the menu. Results should make sense at a glance: titles that name the product or topic, excerpts that distinguish reviews from announcements, and dates where availability or formulations may have changed.
Try spelling variations and the words readers use. Someone may search for “lip stain” when an article calls the product a lip tint, or remember a fragrance’s main note but not its name. If the search tool supports synonyms, use sensible ones. If it does not, clear titles and article text still help. Cramming alternative terms into every heading may catch a query, but it makes the page awkward to read.
No results should not mean no way forward. Let readers revise the search and offer a few dependable destinations, such as the main beauty categories. Unrelated trending stories are not much help to someone looking for a particular foundation shade.
Keep routes clear on a small screen
A mobile menu can exist and still be awkward. Long labels wrap; nested items are fiddly to tap; promotional panels push the section choices out of view. Check common phone widths with the real labels and content, not just a tidy prototype. Tap targets should be distinct, and opening a submenu should not unexpectedly send someone to another page.
On a phone, the page itself has to do more work. An accurate title, concise opening and informative headings help readers confirm that they have found the right story. A breadcrumb can show the way back to the parent section, as long as it reflects the site’s structure. If a post belongs chiefly under Fragrance, do not send its breadcrumb through an unrelated campaign archive just because it mentions an ad.
Check what cards and related links reveal before a tap. Images can dominate a phone screen while titles get cut off. A striking lipstick campaign image cannot tell readers whether the destination is a shade guide, a brand announcement or an opinion piece. Put that distinction in visible text, not a hover effect mobile visitors cannot use.
Make changes in a small, testable order
A full redesign makes it hard to tell which change helped. Begin where readers stumble most: two overlapping categories, an archive full of vague cards or search results that hide article types. Adjust the labels and page copy, then repeat the tasks from the audit. Can people reach the intended page with fewer wrong turns? Can they tell what they will find next?
Record old and new labels, particularly when renaming a section. Editors also need filing rules or the category will drift back into confusion. A note such as “Fragrance holds reviews, note explainers and perfume launch coverage; fashion campaigns primarily about clothing belong elsewhere” can settle future decisions. Revisit it when the publication’s coverage changes, not for every unusual story.
For a first repair, open one crowded archive on a phone. If Fragrance begins with an unlabelled grid of perfume bottles, add a one-sentence description and show three routes—reviews, note guides and launches—using material already on the site. Then ask someone to find a rose-fragrance review without telling them which route to take. Their first tap will tell you more than another round of menu brainstorming.